fbpx
Connect with us

Texas News

Llano County libraries case has lawyers and publishers worried about existing legal precedents

Published

on

Llano County libraries case has lawyers and publishers worried about existing legal precedents

Llano County libraries case has lawyers and publishers worried about existing legal precedents” was first published by The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans — and engages with them — about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune's daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential .


For decades, public libraries across the country — and their staffs — have operated under a modern understanding of court rulings that say books and other materials cannot be removed simply because government officials do not like the ideas they contain.

Advertisement

But as the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals considers a case over library books in Llano County allegedly plucked from shelves for that reason, some library advocates and legal experts are hoping that precedent is upheld.

In interviews, lawyers say that regardless of the ruling to come and any potential broader implications it may bring, they already see an erosion of the respect for libraries and what they represent.

Already, Texas libraries have received a battery of challenges to books, often against award-winning titles for young adults that explore themes of sexuality and race. They have been the recipients of unwelcome, violent threats. They are the targets of new laws, including one in Texas signed into law by Gov. Greg Abbott this month aimed at keeping “sexually explicit” materials off shelves of school libraries. Librarians are concerned the law's broad and vague language will ensnare books that are not inappropriate, and create unrealistic requirements.

“It is a very important case given the context of a public library,” said Matt Stratton, deputy general counsel for the Association of American Publishers, a trade group that — along with six large publishers — filed a brief in support of the plaintiffs in the Llano lawsuit. “The stakes are large when voices are being suppressed.”

The lawsuit against Llano County officials, filed last year by seven patrons of the library system, originates from the removal of 17 titles from the public library system, suspension of access to digital library books and replacement of the county's library board with community members who had favored banning books they see as inappropriate for children, among other allegations.

Advertisement

In March, a federal judge granted the plaintiffs a temporary injunction — ordering the county officials to put the books back on shelves and let people check them out again. The judge also prohibited the defendants, which include the county judge and commissioners, from removing any more books off shelves.

The defendants argue the books were removed during a regular process of reviewing materials, often called “weeding,” and appealed the order in the federal appellate court, which heard oral arguments earlier this month.

Stratton, of the publishing trade group, said the brief it filed was prompted by the appeal and to raise a few key points to the court, including that some of the removed books are among the most honored modern literature. The brief also reiterates, as many others have in relation to this case and others, that the U.S. Constitution does not care for political affiliations in extending its rights.

The 17 titles included one for teens that calls the Ku Klux Klan a terrorist group, Isabel Wilkerson's “Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents” and a comedic children's book from Dawn McMillan's “I Need a New Butt!” series.

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression also filed a brief in support of the plaintiffs that outlined a history of censorship efforts from the public burning of Greek texts in ancient Rome to the current situation in the United States.

Advertisement

“It's important to remember that throughout history, censorship has been the norm,” said Bob Corn-Revere, the organization's chief counsel who wrote the brief. “That's one of the things that makes the United States an exceptional country. … We have been dedicated to the ideals of the enlightenment and freedom of ideas and the right to be exposed to different ideas.”

Libraries were created with that in mind. While some debate the origins of the first library, one theory is that Benjamin Franklin started it in Philadelphia, which FIRE's brief — citing the Library Company of Philadelphia and Franklin's autobiography — pointed to as the country's first successful library that the Founding Father opened because “there was not a good bookseller's shop in any of the colonies to the southward of Boston.”

Over time and historical challenges, ​​Corn-Revere said, the value of a free marketplace of ideas evolved into jurisprudence.

There are various landmark cases that have cemented protections for libraries and librarians, but the overall takeaway of existing library case law is that book removals cannot occur simply because a government official disagrees with the ideas in a book, said Chloe Kempf, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas.

“That is a very clear directive that's ingrained in our country's history,” Kempf said. “In general, the people's First Amendment protections should be at their highest in a public library.”

Advertisement

She added: “Libraries historically are … guardians of our freedom to read and to access information and they exist to preserve information and give us access to an entire range of diverse views.”

That is no different in Texas, where the State Library and Archives Commission since 1997 has endorsed the principles laid out in the American Library Association's Library Bill of Rights, according to the state administrative code. The bill of rights, adopted by an ALA council in 1939, offers seven guiding policies to ensure libraries “are forums for information and ideas.”

State code also defines professional librarians, who curate collections that fill shelves, as people who hold master's degrees in library or information sciences, or a fifth-year degree in librarianship — a level of training that is more stringent in schools, where certified librarians are also required to have at least two years of classroom experience.

To some, the respect such training and values may have once commanded seems to be getting a metaphorical middle finger at the moment.

“We have individuals who are trying to tell us what they believe librarianship is without listening to librarians about what librarianship is all about,” said Deborah Caldwell-Stone, director of ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom and executive director of the Freedom to Read Foundation, about the Llano case. “I do believe that it's an effort to either limit the role of libraries in society or take them away altogether, and I think that that's a tragedy for everyone involved.”

Advertisement

Go behind the headlines with newly announced speakers at the 2023 Texas Tribune Festival, in downtown Austin from Sept. 21-23. Join them to get their take on what's next for Texas and the nation.

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2023/06/19/llano-county-books-legal/.

The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and engaging Texans on state politics and policy. Learn more at texastribune.org.

Did you miss our previous article…
https://www.galvestontrendingnews.com/?p=2478

Advertisement

Texas News

Jason Robertson Powers Stars Over Oilers 5-3 for Lead in Western Conference Final

Published

on

www.wbap.com – – 2024-05-27 23:11:06

SUMMARY: On May 27, 2024, Jason Robertson achieved his first career playoff hat trick as the Dallas Stars defeated the Edmonton Oilers 5-3, leading 2-1 in the NHL’s Western Conference final. Wyatt Johnston and Miro Heiskanen, with an empty-net goal, scored for Dallas, while goalie Jake Oettinger made 26 saves. Roope Hintz, Tyler Seguin, and Jamie Benn each provided two assists. For Edmonton, Connor McDavid scored a goal and an assist, reaching 100 career playoff points, with Zach Hyman and Adam Henrique also scoring. Goalie Stuart Skinner made 17 stops for Edmonton. (Copyright 2024 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.)

Read the full article

The post Jason Robertson Powers Stars Over Oilers 5-3 for Lead in Western Conference Final appeared first on www.wbap.com

Continue Reading

Texas News

Memorial Day safety: 4-year-old found unresponsive in pool at apartment on Greenhouse Road in west Harris County, HCSO says

Published

on

abc13.com – Shannon Ryan – 2024-05-27 21:05:01

SUMMARY: A 4-year-old child was rushed to the hospital after being found unresponsive in a pool at an apartment complex in west Harris County, Houston, on Monday evening. Harris County Sheriff’s Office deputies were dispatched to the scene on Greenhouse Road after receiving a drowning call around 7:23 p.m. The child, who was with family members, went underwater while about 15 to 20 people were in the pool. EMS crews provided CPR and transported the child to the hospital. An investigation is ongoing to determine the circumstances. Follow Shannon Ryan for updates on this developing story.

Read the full article

The post Memorial Day safety: 4-year-old found unresponsive in pool at apartment on Greenhouse Road in west Harris County, HCSO says appeared first on abc13.com

Continue Reading

Texas News

World Health Assembly hopes to reinforce pandemic preparedness – NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth

Published

on

www.nbcdfw.com – Jamey Keaten | Associated Press – 2024-05-27 19:44:50

SUMMARY: Member countries initiated the World Organization's annual assembly to enhance global pandemic preparedness after a proposed “pandemic treaty” faced setbacks. Officials aim to establish new measures for future pandemics as COVID-19 wanes amid other global issues. The treaty's adoption stalled due to disagreements over sharing pathogen information and pandemic-fighting technologies. Amendments to the WHO's International Health Regulations, established in 2004, are now the focus, urging countries to improve alert systems and cooperation. The WHO Director-General remains optimistic about reaching a consensus. A new CDC report confirms COVID-19 vaccines do not cause fatal cardiac issues.

Read the full article

The post World Health Assembly hopes to reinforce pandemic preparedness – NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth appeared first on www.nbcdfw.com

Continue Reading

News from the South

Trending